Manchester City’s guilty verdict over a nine‑year period of financial rule breaches has prompted reactions from several former and current Premier League figures. Michael Carrick, the former Manchester United captain, said that the emotional disappointment of losing the 2011‑12 title to City – when Sergio Agüero’s last‑minute goal at Sunderland denied United the championship – could not be compensated by a winner’s medal. He reflected that the moment of triumph or defeat is irreplaceable, and that the verdict has personally affected him in various ways. Carrick added that, while City continue to appeal, the uncertainty surrounding the case is “not good for anyone” and that a swift resolution would benefit all parties.
The controversy has also reached Liverpool, where manager Andoni Ira Iraola acknowledged the anger felt by Anfield supporters at the club’s alleged misconduct. He urged the Premier League to reach a definitive conclusion quickly, stating that the ongoing uncertainty is harmful to the sport. Ira Iraola, who has not been drawn into the debate while the appeal proceeds, warned that Liverpool’s upcoming match against City will be difficult, especially with the absence of key forwards Alexander Isak and Cody Gakpo due to injuries. He expressed confidence that the squad can still perform well and that the situation provides an opportunity for other players to step up.
Former City captain Vincent Kompany, now Bayern Munich manager, said he remains “really proud” of his achievements with the club, despite the findings. Kompany, who won four Premier League titles and multiple domestic cups between 2008 and 2019, emphasized that as a player he was not involved in off‑pitch matters and that his current focus is on coaching. He reiterated his pride in the club’s on‑field success while distancing himself from the financial allegations.
Arsenal’s new manager Mikel Arteta, who served as Pep Guardiola’s assistant at City for over three years, stated that he would wait for the outcome of City’s appeal before commenting further on the situation. Arteta confirmed that his conscience is clear regarding his time at City, but declined to discuss how the verdict might impact the Premier League’s reputation. He noted that the uncertainty remains outside his control and that once the case is resolved he will speak with clarity. Arsenal and other Premier League clubs have expressed a desire for a prompt conclusion, though City’s appeal could extend the process into the new year.